How to keep the Reader on the edge of his Seat? Joan Aiken writes suspense…

________________________________Silence review_________________________________

The Silence of Herondale  Joan Aiken’s first thriller, published in 1964,  set the style for another dozen or so adult novels which were to follow, alternating with her now much better known children’s books.  Initially published by Gollancz in their famous Yellow Jacket editions, the books were covered in remarkable reviews, like the one above which soon earned her a devoted following. Now,  fifty years after its first appearance, this, and the next five suspense thrillers she wrote are due to come out again, and will hopefully have you reaching for the loofah…


Joan Aiken was sometimes accused of throwing absolutely everything into her novels. Her fertile mind used her plots as a backbone for all the ideas that were currently absorbing her, or were a part of her daily world – music, philosophy, landscapes, travel, people, politics, art, and of course, books. This is not surprising when you look at some of her literary influences, such as John Masefield who enjoyed endless digressions into anything that took his fancy, from church politics to murder mysteries in the local paper while his hero was on the way to buy muffins for tea. Or Dickens, who had the occupational hazard of writing his plots serially, giving him plenty of opportunity to totally change his ideas as better ones came along. Among the writers that Joan Aiken admired, self-discipline was not the order of the day, so much as the ability to enrich a tale by adding whatever embroidery would serve to bend the ear of the listener. She was often compared to Mary Stewart, who was writing at the same time, and used a similar Romantic or Gothic suspense format while also making full use of a wide literary background and extensive education. Aiken’s constantly active imagination, her quirky inventiveness, blended all the available ingredients into a continual tapestry of ‘What if…?’ without in any way detracting from the headlong progress of her story.
Joan Aiken always maintained a firm grip on the plot, and was enormously skilled at keeping the reader on the edge of his seat. If she arrived rather rapidly at her conclusion and found she had too many characters to deal with, she had a cavalier habit of polishing them off in whatever speedy manner came to hand – with automatic hedge clippers, kitchen beater attachments, exploding soup cans or spa-room steam cabinets. Having created some horribly seedy or demented villains, she would show no mercy in dispatching them at the end; she was gleefully ghoulish, but not gory.

Gollancz cover

And her heroines? They were always a version of Joan herself of course, and could be heartlessly thrown in at the deep end. In true Gothic style these hapless heroines would become embroiled in a series of events not of their own making, and were usually possessed of many stalwart characteristics – not least a literary education – if not always endowed with obvious physical charms. Often they were, as she was herself, small, slightly gap toothed, and red haired, but they were generally extremely enterprising, physically intrepid and fearless to the end, and would emerge breathless but undaunted. They were not necessarily rewarded with romance, and on the odd occasion did come to a sad end themselves, but shocked remonstrations from readers discouraged her from allowing this to happen too often.
What comes across most clearly is her impulse to share experiences from her own life; as for example, with the agonising but often hysterical day to day business of living with a slightly dotty old lady, or the frequently curious requirements of a job working in an advertising agency, or even the alarming and humiliating possibilities of being treated in a health spa – all was grist to her mill and became sympathetic background or even foreground, for the novel currently in her imagination. For those who knew her, there was always the dubious pleasure of discovering (albeit disguised!) episodes from their own lives in her books; but when these were re-told with her usual warmth and humour, her intelligence and added insight, one could almost be grateful to have shared a good story with her, and even more so not to have had one’s own experience end in the hair-raising way that she had gone on to imagine it….



See a full list of Joan Aiken’s suspense novels here

Joan’s thrillers available as E Books at Orion’s The Murder Room


12 thoughts on “How to keep the Reader on the edge of his Seat? Joan Aiken writes suspense…

  1. Liz — i left a comment, i think, but to repeat —

    you have wonderful observations on what turned your mother on!



  2. “embroiled in a series of events not of their own making”: very Hitchcockian, but this makes it much easier for us (her happy readers) to get caught up in the stories.

    • Yes that’s the joy of Gothics perhaps? Just enjoyed your Rye post – Joan’s second novel ‘The Fortune Hunters’ is also set there, and makes it very gothic indeed! And you have reminded me to look out the other Rye novel, ‘The Haunting of Lamb House’ – the joy of Joan indeed, always another to re-discover!

      • OK, so now I have a quest: any book by JA on Lamb House is a must read. I can see that your mother’s collected works will keep me occupied for decades to come.

  3. Those yellow jackets — I even think I’ve got a couple of those on my shelves– very nostalgic, but I don’t suppose those Orion reprints will feature these!

    A wonderful evocation of what makes us fans of Joan, Lizza, thanks! What a shame, as Lizzie points out in her recent post, that there’s no obvious sign of her connections with Rye. Anything in Petworth?

  4. The second of these suspense novels is actually set in Rye – but she often changes the names of her settings. In fact Joan made use of many of her own houses, and set a historical trilogy in and around her house, The Hermitage in Petworth – The Smile of the Stranger, The Weeping Ash and The Girl from Paris – plus there’s a very spooky YA ‘Return to Harken House’ which describes a summer re-visiting Rye, and that lonely haunted house, just before the outbreak of WW11 when her father had forgotten she was expected…
    You shouldn’t have asked! I can keep you busy with a TBR list to die for…
    And lovely Sussex tribute ‘The Cuckoo Tree’ as Dido is returning to Joan’s Petworth roots!

    • Yes, loved ‘The Cuckoo Tree’! Am I right in thinking that the grand house (forgotten the name at the moment) opposite Dog Kennel Cottages is based on Petworth House? Google Earth and Google maps suggest there is no mansion on that scale there…

  5. Pingback: Utopian publisher seeks humane thrillers…from Joan Aiken of course | Joan Aiken

Leave a Comment?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s